Indian-ish Deli · West Village
By Monty Khas, Anonymous Critic. Pays every bill.
The best sandwich shops are built on obsession, and Fonty's founders admit theirs freely. Varsha Harlalka and Viraj Borkar grew up in Assam eating one kind of sandwich; Harlalka's husband, Arjun Gupta, grew up in Tampa eating another. Fonty's Deli + Dukaan, on a crooked stretch of Christopher Street, is what happens when the two traditions finally share a counter.
The place
The trio already runs Fontainhas, a Brooklyn cafe named for the old Latin Quarter of Goa, and Fonty's is its younger, scrappier sibling. Up front, a busy sandwich counter sits among shelves of desi pantry goods from small producers, the dukaan half of the name. Walk past it and there's a quiet back room with a handful of tables and a fireplace, one of the better hideaways in the Village. Doors open at 7 a.m. and stay open until 11 p.m.
The food
Start with the Naanini, the sandwich that put lines down the block. Freshly baked naan is filled and pressed like a panini until the edges crisp and the cheese gives way. Chicken tikka is the version to beat, smoky and saucy, with pickled onions cutting the richness; Kerala beef and chana masala are worthy alternates. It is messy by design. Grab extra napkins.
The Bombay sandwich is the purist's order. Spiced potato, peppers, onion and tomato, a slick of cilantro-mint chutney and salty Amul cheese are toasted between thin Pullman slices until the whole thing eats like a handheld plate of chaat. The cheese chutney sandwich, sharpened with green chili, is Mumbai school-canteen nostalgia. On the deli side, the Parsi stacks mortadella and salami with a hot spread and pickled cucumbers, and the tuna melt gets green chilies, lime and cilantro. Vegetarians get one of the longest lists of any Manhattan deli. Pair it with South Indian filter coffee or a dirty chai.
Why it matters
Plenty of places put tikka in bread. Fonty's actually thinks about the sandwich as a sandwich: the bread, the press, the ratio of sauce to crunch. The result reads less like fusion than like a family recipe box shared between two countries, and it's the most inventive desi sandwich board in Manhattan.
The Quick Fix
What to order: Chicken tikka Naanini; Bombay sandwich; cheese chutney sandwich; the Parsi; South Indian filter coffee
Pricing: Budget to mid-range. Deli prices with a West Village address.
Best for: Breakfast meetings, solo lunches, vegetarians and slow afternoons in the back room
How it compares: Gentler on the heat than Rowdy Rooster and more polished than Nishaan's griddle-and-go energy. Its Bombay sandwich is the closest thing in Manhattan to the Mumbai original.
See where it ranks: The Best Street Food to Indulge In: Desi Sandwich Specials and More
The food was always this good. We're just paying attention.