Pakistani-American Sandwiches · East Village
By Monty Khas, Anonymous Critic. Pays every bill.
The chopped cheese is New York's most loyal sandwich, born on a bodega griddle and defended like a family heirloom. It takes nerve to rewrite it. Zeeshan Bakhrani did it with a chapli kabob, and the East Village has been lining up ever since.
The story
Bakhrani grew up Pakistani and American, moved from Chicago to New York in 2022 and was working in tech until a layoff pushed him toward the griddle. A sandwich collaboration led to a Smorgasburg booth, the booth led to a truck, and the truck won season 18 of The Great Food Truck Race. He opened the First Avenue restaurant quietly, before the show even aired, and let the food make the noise.
The food
The chapli kabob chopped cheese is the reason you're here. Rather than dropping a whole kebab into a bun, Bakhrani breaks the Peshawari classic down to its spice DNA, then griddles and chops halal beef with onions and peppers, melts American and pepper jack through it, and finishes it with tamarind chutney and a lime-cilantro sauce in a long roll. It is unmistakably a chopped cheese, juicy and dripping, with the warm, coriander-heavy perfume of a frontier grill. A chicken version is there for non-beef eaters.
The Buffalo tandoori chicken sandwich runs a close second: tandoori-spiced chicken hit with Buffalo heat and cooled with a mint-chutney ranch that deserves its own bottle. The Bihari barbacoa tacos fold slow-braised, smoky beef into tortillas, and the Pakistani achari cheesesteak brings pickle-spice tang to Philadelphia's favorite. Don't skip the elotes chaat, a chaat-style riff on Mexican street corn, or loaded fries piled with chapli kabob or barbacoa. Sandwiches are big, so sharing is smart.
The room
It's tiny, with about ten seats inside and a few sidewalk tables, and it fills fast. The crowd mixes Pakistani families, students and chopped-cheese loyalists who came to argue and stayed for a second sandwich.
Why it matters
Desi-American mashups are easy to make and hard to make well. Nishaan works because it respects both sides of the hyphen, and because the chopped cheese still tastes like New York. It is the most exciting Pakistani sandwich in the city right now.
The Quick Fix
What to order: Chapli kabob chopped cheese; Buffalo tandoori chicken sandwich; Bihari barbacoa tacos; elotes chaat; chapli loaded fries
Pricing: Budget. Big sandwiches, easily shared.
Best for: Casual dinners, halal eaters, groups who share and anyone who thinks the chopped cheese cannot be improved
How it compares: Beefier and richer than Rowdy Rooster's chicken, and louder than Fonty's Naanini. After the sandwich, walk a few blocks south for a cup at Kolkata Chai Co.
See where it ranks: The Best Street Food to Indulge In: Desi Sandwich Specials and More
The food was always this good. We're just paying attention.